Episode Four: What If Colonialism Had Never Happened?


Pacific and Caribbean Islands… When the Identity of Tourist Destinations Changed

In the previous episodes of our series “What If Colonialism Had Never Happened?”, we explored how colonialism reshaped the global tourism map, looking at the Maya civilization and African kingdoms, and the destruction and looting of their heritage.

In this fourth episode, we turn to the world of islands, where we uncover a striking paradox: some destinations marketed today as tourist paradises have a history of kingdoms being overthrown, Indigenous communities marginalized, and cultural identities reshaped.

Hawaii… A Kingdom Transformed into a Tourist Destination

Before Hawaii became one of the world’s most famous tourist destinations, it was an independent, unified kingdom dating back to 1810, with its own system of government, culture, language, and traditions.

But American economic and political influence grew throughout the 19th century, particularly as sugar plantation owners expanded their interests.

On January 17, 1893, Queen Liliʻuokalani was overthrown with the support of a group of American businessmen and the involvement of American military personnel. The islands were then formally annexed by the United States in 1898.
Episode Four: What If Colonialism Had Never Happened?


The change was not merely political. The local language and culture were marginalized, and traditional practices such as hula dance declined amid restrictions and religious criticism, before later regaining their presence.

As tourism grew, some cultural expressions became entertainment performances for visitors, while aspects of Indigenous history and the struggle for identity and sovereignty remained less visible in the traditional tourism narrative.

The Caribbean… Peoples Who Never Disappeared Despite Colonialism

Across the Caribbean islands, Indigenous peoples, most notably the Taíno, lived in organized communities before Christopher Columbus arrived in 1492.

The Taíno had social and political systems, along with expertise in agriculture, navigation, toolmaking, and the arts.

But the Spanish invasion, followed by disease, enslavement, and violence, led to widespread population and cultural collapse over the following decades.

Still, it is inaccurate to say the Taíno disappeared entirely. Their legacy lives on in Caribbean cultures, languages, and music. Historical and genetic studies also confirm the continued presence of Indigenous ancestry among communities in the region, while contemporary groups continue to express their Taíno identity.

What Did the Tourism World Lose?

The experiences of Hawaii and the Caribbean reveal that tourism can successfully market natural beauty, but sometimes reduces a destination to beaches, hotels, and entertainment, leaving the history of its Indigenous peoples out of the picture.

Hawaii is more than tropical beaches and traditional dances, and the Caribbean is more than islands and resorts. Behind every destination lies a history of cultures, languages, resistance, and social transformation.

Had these islands been able to follow their cultural and political paths without colonial intervention, they might have developed more diverse tourism experiences today, reflecting their local identities and history in greater depth.

The challenge facing modern tourism is not simply attracting visitors, but presenting a destination’s history honestly, involving Indigenous communities in telling their stories, and ensuring that their cultures are not reduced to commercial products.

A tourist does not truly discover a place by seeing its beauty alone, but by understanding its story as well.

In Episode Five, we open another chapter in the story of colonialism: the world’s museums. We ask how thousands of archaeological artifacts made their way from their countries of origin into collections and museums far away, and what this means for the future of cultural tourism.